The following is an exchange with a commentor on Marty Rathbun’s blog named Conan.
In this exchange, I was able to clearly and simply express what I have learned that L Ron Hubbard was really up to with Scientology.
I appreciate the softballs that Conan threw me which allowed me to finally knock this idea out. I’ve tried many times over the years to simply communicate what I have learned about Scientology, and I guess having been subjected to Scientology’s brainwashing tactics myself, it has been very difficult for me to crystallize these ideas and to simply and clearly communicate them.
It was a kind of personal victory – something I’ve been trying to accomplish for years.
I think I finally did it.
The excellent article that Marty Rathbun wrote, and which prompted this exchange, can be read here: Scientology Indoctrination Abomination
I took a statement that Marty made out of his article, and commented on it.
“So thorough is Hubbard’s ‘tech’ for ferreting out and disappearing ‘false data’ that conflicts with his data, ironically, that those steps applied to one’s scientology experience could actually de-hypnotize someone from years of mind control programming. “
This is a very important point, Marty.
I have seen the Scientology mindset collapse in just this way on a number of Scientologists over the years.
For me, the concept of “intellectual honesty” was a datum from the value system I held before I had become a Scientologist. When I focused on this concept again, after years in, Scientology just started collapsing all around me.
A writer friend of mine and I were discussing being a member of an ideology and trying to write true things. His contention was that you couldn’t because when you are pushing an ideology, you have to make wrong anything that opposes the ideology, or what shows the ideology to be false – even though it might be true.
The topic between us became “what is intellectual honesty and how do you apply it as a member of an ideology?”
I had grown up valuing intellectual honesty. My father was an engineer and my mother a highly literate and well read woman who encouraged literacy and critical thinking in me. I realized that this value system of mine had been lost when I became a Scientologist.
Scientology was pretty much done for me when I saw that. It just started collapsing everywhere around me.
And then I made the decision to never lie about Scientology again. And that’s what eventually made me an “SP” and brought OSA down on me.
If a Scientologist compares points of his present value system as a Scientologist with points in his earlier value system, and he begins to see the values he gave up in order to become a Scientologist, Scientology will collapse on him.
Hubbard knew this and talked about it on the BC, especially on the tape “Moral Codes, What is a Withhold?” That tape, more than almost any other, reveals what Hubbard was actually working on when he ran the BC. He was trying to create synthetic personalities, complete with moral codes, that he could instill and maintain in people who would do his bidding.
When he took off and developed the Sea Org, he implemented this brainwashing technology he developed on the BC on a group of people he could have total control over on a ship in the middle of the ocean.
Hubbard very intentionally created and instilled brainwashing techniques into Scientology. And you are touching on the very points that will undo it.
Way to go, Marty.
Way to go.
Conan | September 21, 2014 at 9:10 am | Reply
“Hubbard knew this and talked about it on the BC, especially on the tape “Moral Codes, What is a Withhold?” That tape, more than almost any other, reveals what Hubbard was actually working on when he ran the BC. He was trying to create synthetic personalities, complete with moral codes, that he could instill and maintain in people who would do his bidding.”
Are you referring to some angle other than his usual what others have done to us?
Please elaborate a bit more about the “how to create synthetic personalities”.
Alanzo | September 21, 2014 at 9:55 am | Reply
“Are you referring to some angle other than his usual what others have done to us?
Please elaborate a bit more about the “how to create synthetic personalities”.
There is a public congress tape series, which I can’t remember the name of, from the late 50’s, maybe even early 60’s, where he presents the GPM tech, which he had been developing on the BC, to the public for the first time.
In one of his lectures there, he says that he has “discovered what a personality is made up of”.
Now, that is not what he ever said about GPMs on the BC, that I can remember. He always told BC students that this was “how the case was constructed” and this was the whole reason for his “research line” – to create “Clears” and “OT”s.
Most techniques of brainwashing – not just influence – target the self-identity of the person you are trying to control by replacing it with a self-identity that you have developed.
Remember, a self-identity is who you tell yourself you are. This is the key element of this form of extreme brainwashing. If you can change who a person tells himself he is to something that you can control, then you have someone whose very life is spent doing what you want him to do.
Some of the core pieces of your self identity are your memories (which Hubbard had always targeted with auditing), your goals (which Hubbard targeted on the BC with his SOP Goals tech, and later the GPM tech, and still later FPRD tech) and your moral codes or value systems, which he targeted using all forms of OW write ups and sec checking.
Over time, Hubbard developed auditing as a gradient form of brainwashing to replace the self-identity that you were born with, and which you had been developing all your life, with a self-identity that had the memories and goals and moral codes that he could control.
The BC was his Edison-style inventor’s laboratory where the BC students, who paid him to be there, were his lab rats and co-developers.
And then the Sea Org was the highly controlled environment he created to apply what he had developed on the BC in order to produce a core group of brainwashed followers whose memories, goals and moral codes had been fully supplanted and who would do anything he told them to do, all on billion year slave labor contracts.
From the use of TRs to create a hypnotic state in the pc, to the creation of false memories, to the development of SOP Goals, Sec Checking and GPM tech, Hubbard was doing something very different from what he was telling anyone else about.
Scientologists were reaching for Clear and OT while Hubbard was always targeting them for everything of value that they had.
This is the “long con” which L Ron Hubbard spent decades of work developing as Dianetics and Scientology.
Conan | September 21, 2014 at 11:27 am | Reply
Thanks for your great exposition of Hubbard’s final intent.
I too observed that was were the ship was going when I was in the SO. But I did not have the mental capacity to actually comprehend what was taking place, let alone be able to articulate the fine points of mind control, entrapment, etc..
I’m telling you this has been an incredible education for me, however tough, I’m happy that I know why I know now.
Alanzo | September 21, 2014 at 11:38 am | Reply
“I’m telling you this has been an incredible education for me, however tough, I’m happy that I know why I know now.”
It has been for me as well.
It is the oddest thing ever that learning about what Hubbard was really up to with Scientology has been one of my greatest spiritual lessons of this lifetime so far.
This technology of brainwashing is being used in Guantanamo Bay, in North Korea, in China and elsewhere.
When it is applied in a spiritual context, as it was in Scientology, it is the most profane corruption of the best impulses in human beings.
For some reason, coming to see this has been a huge spiritual “win” for me, helping me to understand things that I always wanted to understand.
Here’s some more information on brainwashing.